Reviews

What We’re Reading: May 2026

Curated by KEI LIM

With our spring issue hot off the press, check out these recommendations from three of the issue’s contributors: LIZ DEWOLF, ANDREW STEINER, and MARIA TERRONE.

 

Book cover of Beautiful Days by Zach Williams

Zach Williams’ Beautiful Days, recommended by Issue 31 contributor Liz DeWolf

I first came across Zach Williams’ work when I read his 2022 story “Wood Sorrel House” in The New Yorker. The story, in which a family arrives at a rental cabin and then forgets everything about their lives before, including how they got there, deeply unsettled me. Something about Williams’s careful, straightforward prose makes each disturbing revelation—The baby doesn’t age while the parents do! Food mysteriously appears in the freezer!—all the more destabilizing.

I recently read Williams’s debut collection Beautiful Days, which came out in 2024 and includes “Wood Sorrel House” as well as nine other, equally unnerving stories. In “Trial Run,” an office worker gets sucked into an overly intimate dynamic a with a clingy colleague. The protagonist of the story “Neighbors” goes to check on the elderly woman next door and finds himself in a confusing standoff with a masked intruder. In “Mousetraps,” one of my favorites from the collection, a father goes to the hardware store looking for a humane way to get rid of mice only to be goaded into an existential crisis by the men who run the business. What makes these stories so compelling, beyond their dreamy logic and ability to reflect so many fears of contemporary life, is that they each contain some moment of connection, however unwelcome, that acts as a sort of escape hatch from the mundane. On the other side of each unpleasant encounter is a hint of excitement or possibility: the dull neighborhood is more lively than it seems, the identity crisis leads to a new start, the paranoid brother really does perceive something others can’t. There’s an unlikely tenderness—maybe even hopefulness, however slight—in this collection that echoes its title, drawn from the surprisingly optimistic final line of “Wood Sorrel House”: “There will be beautiful days.” The stories are as thrilling as they are terrifying, and this dissonance produces a haunting ambiguity that stayed with me long after I finished reading.

 

Book Cover of The Hill of Dreams

 

Arthur Machen’s The Hill of Dreams, recommended by Issue 31 contributor Andrew Steiner

Lucian Taylor, a parson’s son, grows up in the Welsh village of Caermaen. His childhood is ordinary — not abundant, but loving, secure. And then when he’s fifteen, everything changes.

Home for the summer holidays, he gets the itch to walk. The wind is up, the air charged with a violent heat. A strange light in the sky frames the ruins of the old Roman fort on the hill above the village. On hands and knees, he mounts the hill, pushes through the bracken, and there in the secret center of the ruin … something happens.

Divine showing? Demonic encounter? Guilty autoerotic experiment?

Whatever it is, Lucian climbs down changed, unable to share what has happened to him yet persuaded the dull scrim has been torn off the world and he has glimpsed a sublime and terrible reality.

He is determined to capture that reality in writing. The quest to do so will consume his life.

Arthur Machen began writing The Hill of Dreams in 1895, the dead center of the decade that produced Dracula, Dorian Gray, The Time Machine, and other seminal works of fantasy and horror. Unlike its contemporaries — and much of Machen’s own work, including The Great God PanThe Hill is not a work of fantasy. It’s a realist novel about the kind of person driven to write a work of fantasy.

The act of writing for Lucian is not a matter of discipline. Nor is it something sanctified like “a vocation.” It’s closer to damnation, a claim on his soul.

As the plot unfolds along the inevitable lines of tragedy, you watch him feed more and more of his life into the furnace of writing. Like a dark god, it demands ever dearer sacrifices — his health, his schooling, his relationship with his father, his prospects for any viable career whatsoever — until he has nothing left to give it but the last thing.

Machen’s vision is certainly extreme. Yet if you’ve ever found yourself years into a project that seems no closer to completion, his depiction of the ground-level experience of writing will be entirely legible:

He had put away the old wild hopes of the masterpiece conceived and executed in a fury of inspiration, wrought out in one white heat of creative joy; it was enough if by dint of long perseverance and singleness of desire he could at last, in pain and agony and despair, after failure and disappointment and effort constantly renewed, fashion something of which he need not be ashamed.

To date it’s the best book I’ve read about being a young, obsessive would-be writer drunk on language and in thrall to fantasy. It brought back all the dear, dark feelings Tolkien and Lewis, Lilith and A Voyage to Arcturus first quickened in me in adolescence. It showed me what it would have been like to tip over the edge and vanish entirely into dreams.

How did I not come across it then? Could I have survived it if I had?

 

Book cover of Delirium
 

Laura Restrepo’s Delirium, recommended by Issue 31 Maria Terrone

If I had never been the target of a scam literary impersonation, I would have never discovered the fascinating Colombian-born novelist Laura Restrepo.

For about five days, I exchanged long, friendly emails daily with “Laura,” whose initial subject line was “Connecting Over Writing, Inspiration, and Shared Passions.” I’d never heard of this author—my only knowledge of Latin American writing was limited to the magical realism of Gabriel García Márquez. Through research, I learned that Restrepo was originally a political journalist covering drug cartels and fled to Mexico following death threats. She now lives in Spain.

During our literary exchanges—before I learned through my own investigation that “Laura” was an AI-generated bot—I asked her which novel would best acquaint me with her work. Delirium was the immediate reply. It turned out to be, by far, one of the strangest and most mesmerizing books I’ve every read, winner of the prestigious Afaguara Novel Prize, which guaranteed its publication across Spain and Latin America.

Delirium opens in media res. Augustina, a beautiful woman from a wealthy Columbian family, is discovered alone, amnesiac, and incoherent in a 5-star Bogotá hotel after her husband returns from a short trip. How did she get there? What caused her madness? Why does this deeply disturbed young woman who always called herself a seer now rage against her husband, Aguilar? “The woman I love is lost inside her head and for fourteen days now I’ve been searching for her,” he laments early in his quest.

Mystery, love story, political exposé, Delirium delves deeply on both a psychological and journalistic level. The tale takes place against Columbia’s backdrop of corruption and political chaos in the 1980s, when the military, guerillas and drug dealers warred with one another. In a sense, Augustina’s breakdown mirrors that bedlam. Her ritualistic house-cleaning and demand that Aguilar confine himself to an increasingly smaller space against a wall in their apartment seems to be a desperate attempt to exert control over her own demons and, symbolically, over her beloved nation’s parallel breakdown.

The story is told from many characters’ voices and perspectives, shifting between past and present and back again. Writing clearly and vividly, Restrepo avoids confusing the reader despite the complexity of the narrative and her nonlinear approach. Gradually the roots of Augustina’s derangement are revealed, especially via the tragic, sometimes harrowing flashbacks to her dysfunctional family. At times I felt I was immersed in a gripping detective novel.

As I watched Aguilar struggle to investigate and understand his wife’s new persona, I appreciated the irony of my own search to discover the identity of the impersonator who approached me so warmly as Restrepo. Of course, the truth disappointed, but the unexpected gift resulting from my bizarre experience was my first exposure to Restrepo’s brilliant fiction. One novel down, eleven waiting.

What We’re Reading: May 2026
Read more...

Book Review: Exemplary Humans

By JULIANA LEITE
Translated by ZOË PERRY

Reviewed by JAY BOSS RUBIN

Book cover of Exemplary Humans

In the opening chapter of this subtle epic, the centenarian narrator Natalia confides: “At this point in life, I’d say that going on forever or for too long is a bad decision, a very bad one; what’s nice is to exist and then stop existing, to exist for a while and then be able to change the subject.” In other words, if the transition between life and death is an abrupt one, then so be it. “[L]et’s be done with it,” she says, “though it would be nice to have the time to spritz on some perfume beforehand.”

When I first encountered this sentiment in Juliana Leite’s Exemplary Humans, translated from the Portuguese by Zoë Perry, I took it be a bit of a bluff. It reminded me of a bumper sticker I saw a couple of years ago in Portland, Oregon, that read: “I ♥ AGING & DYING” (which I interpreted as an existentialist rejoinder to proclamations of commercial allegiance—“I ♥ Mr Plywood” and so on—so common in my hometown). But by the end of Leite’s novel, which takes place primarily in Rio de Janeiro and Petrópolis, Brazil, and spans that country’s lengthy dictatorship, I was convinced that Natalia’s breezy acceptance of her own mortality was absolutely serious. It is not only possible, but strongly advised to love aging and dying. It isn’t easy, though. To transcend dread, and transform it into something more palatable, a unique kind of emotional intelligence is required, and so is a talent for adjusting one’s perspectives. Natalia is the novel’s exemplar of both these qualities.

Book Review: Exemplary Humans
Read more...

Review of Pastorals by Rachel Hadas

By RACHEL HADAS

Reviewed by REEVE LINDBERGH

Book cover of Pastorals by Rachel Hadas

Rachel Hadas is a close friend, someone I have known since the early 1970’s, and a summer neighbor in rural Vermont. She lives in a house that has belonged to her family, one generation following the other for many decades. Her new book, Pastorals, is an exquisitely written collection of brief reflections and meditations essentially but not exclusively centered on the house.

“Can one feel nostalgic for the present, especially when it’s layered so palpably over the past?” The writer asks herself this at the beginning of the book. Within the present as she lives and writes are the unseen presences of those who have visited or inhabited the same dwelling in the same place. They are not exactly ghosts but instead “the presence of an absence,” something Hadas feels at odd moments indoors or out: while going up the stairs; in the midst of picking blackberries on the hill; on the way down the dirt road to the mailbox. She likens these “seasonal phantoms” in her summer house to the ghosts in Walter De La Mere’s poem “The Listeners,” a poem that had puzzled but did not frighten her when she read it as a child. Readers of Pastorals will learn quickly that Hadas’s memory is filled with the poetry and prose of every age and nation along with her own beloved family ghosts.

Review of Pastorals by Rachel Hadas
Read more...

The Art of Unsettling: The Complexities of Freedom and Fidelity in Edy Poppy’s Anatomy. Monotony.

By EDY POPPY

Reviewed by BRITTA STROMEYER

 

“For my husband, who has given me everything, even what I didn’t want. (He’s now my ex-husband.)” reads the dedication in Edy Poppy’s award-winning and spicy debut novel Anatomy. Monotony. It’s an irresistible hook, inviting the reader into a novel that explores the author’s experiences in an open marriage, the evolving sense of place as a search for identity, and the adventure and challenges inherent in the act of writing itself:

“I want to write about the people, the loneliness, and the language here. I feel at home but I’m a stranger, don’t belong, can’t express what I truly feel.”

The Art of Unsettling: The Complexities of Freedom and Fidelity in Edy Poppy’s Anatomy. Monotony.
Read more...

Review: Stories From the Edge of the Sea

By OLGA ZILBERBOURG

Book cover of Stories from the Edge of the Sea

Many fiction writers aspire to mastery of the short story form. From commercial offerings such as the “MasterClass” online series to college curricula, we are taught techniques to create a strong character and a plot leading to a resolution. The goal? “To uncover a single incidence or series of linked incidents, aiming to evoke a single effect or mood from the reader,” as phrased by Sughnen Yongo writing for Forbes. I’m convinced that this conventional attitude that expects singleness from the short story is selling it short.

In his latest collection Stories from the Edge of the Sea, Andrew Lam delivers work far beyond that narrow definition of the form. The settings are complex. Even a five-page story can encompass several decades of a character’s life. Though many pieces focus on a single protagonist, often the cast of characters is big enough for a multigenerational saga. Sometimes, the perspective shifts unexpectedly from one character to another across time and space, and in other stories a first-person narrator’s voice that begins a story disappears and the story continues in the third person, as though looking over the shoulder of the earlier first-person narrator. The emotional effects of these fourteen stories are layered; they leave us with no easy truths, but push us away from stable shores into the stormy seas of human experience.

Review: Stories From the Edge of the Sea
Read more...

What We’re Reading: September 2025

Curated by KEI LIM

This month’s picks span extraordinary circumstances, yet tug at the rather ordinary, or perhaps most relatable, of emotions. AFTON MONTGOMERY recommends an investigative nonfiction book that interrogates people’s relationships to forever chemicals, VICTORIA KELLY recommends the 2024 Booker Prize Winner that abandons plot and follows a 24-hour period of astronauts orbiting Earth, and MONIKA CASSEL recommends a docupoetics collection that weaves the emotional aftermath of the Vietnam War with the defiance of women throughout history and literature.

 

What We’re Reading: September 2025
Read more...

What We’re Reading: August 2025

Curated by KEI LIM

The summer months for The Common’s staff have been filled with wandering, around Western Massachusetts and beyond. Throughout this wandering, we’ve carried books which roam themselves, where relationships parallel the movements of the landscapes they traverse. Editorial Assistants BEN TAMBURRI, LUCHIK BELAU- LORBERG, and CLARA CHIU, and Applefield Fellow AIDAN COOPER recommend three novels and a poetry collection which brought them solace during these long, sweltry days.

Cover of Willa Cather's O Pioneers!

Willa Cather’s O Pioneers!, recommended by David Applefield ’78 Fellow Aidan Cooper 

Anyone who knows me knows I can’t stand audiobooks. There’s something about the pace or the performances that irks me, or maybe it’s something about being slightly insoluble in the story, while I drive, or fold laundry, or task my hands with whatever it is that isn’t turning a page. For me, reading has always been about following and, more importantly, re-following where the words before me lead; I flip here and there, underline and annotate, and generally meander through and indulge in the language’s turns. But because this summer has been one interwoven with travel, tugged along by the two yellow lines in our potholed New England roads, I decided (betraying my brand) to put O Pioneers! by Willa Cather through my car radio.

What We’re Reading: August 2025
Read more...